Book Excerpts

A Deeper Look at the Humanitarian Crisis in Assam: No Land’s People | EXCERPT

No Land’s People documents the unfolding humanitarian crisis in Assam’s citizenship tangle, juxtaposes it with the complications of the NRC process while exploring technical, social and legal aspects of the exercise.

ONE day in 1949, my grandmother, then all of seven, walked from East Pakistan into India holding her father’s hand. Their lives had been uprooted by a line drawn on a map by a British lawyer who had just five weeks to divide a country. They left their home for India, carrying only a few bundles of clothes and utensils. Seventy years later, Alata Rani Saha failed to make it to a list of Indian citizens in the state of Assam.

The National Register of Citizens (NRC) in Assam sought to establish the Indian citizenship of its residents and thereby weed out the non-citizens. The exercise was ‘the first of its kind in the history of the country’. It reimagined how the Indian state relates to its citizens. It was carried out following a Supreme Court order and, more importantly, under the apex court’s continuous supervision. An ethnically diverse state trusted bureaucrats and technology to solve a sociopolitical problem—at a cost of over Rs 1,600 crore to the exchequer.

To make it to the NRC, around 3.3 crore people, supported by over 6.6 crore documents, attempted to prove that they or their ancestors had been in Assam or anywhere else in India before the midnight of 24 March 1971— the unique cut-off date for identifying Indian citizens in Assam. In the process, documentary evidence and oral statements converged to establish a person’s citizenship.

Assam is a border state in India’s northeast, dotted with hills, jungles, rivers and valleys. The state, known globally for its tea and one-horned rhinos, is home to several ethnic, religious and linguistic communities. Its history is one of large-scale migrations. Its tea plantations, oilfields and coalfields attracted migrant workers from eastern and central India. Hindu Bengalis, fluent in English, came to avail themselves of fresh opportunities that colonial rule opened up, leading to allegations of their hegemony over the Assamese; landless Muslim peasants from East Bengal came to cultivate the fertile land, encouraged by colonial policies and some Muslim leaders; Marwaris from Rajasthan arrived to trade; Nepalis came as soldiers and cattle herders; and refugees from East Pakistan came in batches after Partition. The state went through decades of militancy and counter-insurgency operations, and also witnessed ethnic strife.

The issue of migrant communities from what is now Bangladesh posing a demographic, political and cultural threat to the original inhabitants of the state has been a longstanding one in the Assamese consciousness. It has dominated the state’s sociopolitical discourse. But people’s movements, political assurances, and enactment of special legal and administrative provisions—all failed to resolve the problem, which endures even after seventy-three years of India’s Independence. Against such a backdrop emerged the demand for the NRC—a list which sought to separate the citizen from the non-citizen. The NRC was pitched as if it were a magic wand designed to solve Assam’s ‘foreigner’ problem, coming as it did after decades of ethno-nationalist struggle and conflict in the state. It was conceptualized and ideologically supported as an essential tool to check undocumented and illegal migration into Assam which, it was believed, threatened the interests of the indigenous people of the state.

The NRC rejected over 19 lakh applicants, putting them at risk of becoming stateless. For the people who claimed to be Indian citizens but were unable to prove their claim by the yardstick of the NRC, this signified persecution. A vast majority of them said they would fight tooth and nail to prove their citizenship. At the opposite end of the spectrum, several key stakeholders, including the Sarbananda Sonowal–led Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government in Assam and the powerful All Assam Students Union (AASU), which had spearheaded the demand for an updated NRC since the 1980s, were dissatisfied with the NRC norms. They argued that the number of excluded persons should have been higher, that the process was erroneous and that there were wrongful inclusions and exclusions in the final list. The Assam government said it did not accept the published NRC and sought re-verification of the names included in it.3

The BJP, which swept to power in Assam in 2016, was unhappy because among the 19 lakh excluded were a large number of Hindus, primarily Bengalis, who, observers say4, form a solid voter base in the state for the party.5 Muslims of Bengali descent, a community that suffers an identity crisis in Assam and is often vilified, did not register as high a percentage of exclusion as the BJP probably expected it to. Much of the saffron party’s political rhetoric in Assam targets and others this community.

In the BJP’s political imagination, an undocumented Hindu migrant could never be a ‘foreigner’ in India. It was to ratify this fundamental stand that the party pushed for the Citizenship (Amendment) Act (CAA). This contentious law was passed by the Indian parliament in December 2019. The CAA relaxed the eligibility norms for Indian citizenship6 for Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis and Christians who had come to India from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan.

In Assam, especially in the largely Assamese-speaking Brahmaputra Valley region that has a multitude of ethnic communities, the BJP faced stiff opposition over the CAA. Many considered the amended law as a threat to the indigenous people and violative of the terms of the Assam Accord of 1985. The CAA reignited an old fear among the Assamese—of sociocultural inundation by the Bengali migrant, whatever that migrant’s religion. The BJP pitched the CAA as a panacea for the Hindu Bengalis left out of the NRC in Assam, but in doing so it completely overlooked the fact that many migrants, like my grandmother, were anyway eligible for inclusion under existing laws, if only the state machinery processes were fairer.

In the national sphere, advancing on its Hindu nationalist political agenda, the BJP pitched a pan-India NRC coupled with the CAA—implying that non-Muslims who might not have the requisite citizenship papers would be covered by the CAA. But the ghuspetiya or the infiltrator—read Muslims without documents— would be evicted from the country. When massive protests broke out across the country in late 2019, Prime Minister Narendra Modi backtracked and said that neither in the parliament nor in the cabinet had there been any discussion at all regarding a pan-India NRC.

In May 2018, when I started covering the northeast for the Indian Express, the biggest story unfolding in Assam was the NRC. The first draft list was already out and the second was on its way. People were scrambling for ancestral documents as they prepared to attend official verification hearings.

With this job I came back home after nine years. I had been away, first studying civil engineering at a university in Jharkhand, and then journalism in Chennai. I worked as a journalist in Delhi and Kashmir for another four years. Despite being a grandson of Bengali refugees from the erstwhile East Pakistan, the culture I was brought up in was syncretic and inclusive. Neither were the times such that old fault-lines resurfaced to largely divide people. My days growing up in Guwahati were rather protected, far removed from the ethno-linguistic political narrative of the state. I schooled at a reputed convent school for boys in the city and my closest friends belonged to influential Assamese families. My parents, both doctors, ensured that contestations over Assamese and Bengali identities did not become table talk over dinner. I did not study Bengali as a regional language in school but took up Assamese and Hindi. As a teenager I was equally hooked to Assamese and Bengali pop music. Two of my uncles were married into Assamese families. But living in denial hardly guarantees an escape from the sociopolitical quicksand surrounding you.

As a journalist I covered the NRC exercise dispassionately…the procedural steps involved, the major controversies, people’s rush to meet deadlines, and the plight of those excluded. I extensively reported on how the battles to prove one’s citizenship in Assam affected the ordinary person, the worst sufferers being the poor and the illiterate, most of whom belonged to the religious and linguistic minorities of the state. Alongside, as a grandson of migrants, I tried to understand my Thakuma’s (grandmother’s) predicament and why she was a ‘doubtful’ citizen. What I stumbled upon was a web of complex citizenship-determination mechanisms. For years, these processes, marked by systemic flaws, have snatched away people’s citizenship rights with impunity.

People excluded from the Assam NRC would appeal to the state’s foreigners tribunals (FTs). Those who failed to establish their citizenship here, and hence were declared non-citizens, stood the risk of incarceration in detention centres because their deportation to Bangladesh is rather improbable.

Thakuma too will appeal against her exclusion at an FT. She has been blind for a few years now. Her retina, doctors say, have degenerated irreversibly with age. Her body is frail and weak, and her hair grey and thin. She will not be able to read or sign legal documents. I worry about whether she will be able to answer difficult questions about her life in Assam—for instance, the specific dates of her migration and marriage—to the tribunal’s satisfaction. Thakuma’s story compelled me to look inward while reporting on the NRC. Assam’s citizenship imbroglio is a deeply personal story for me; it strikes at the core of my being. This book is an attempt to document and understand the unfolding humanitarian crisis in Assam.

To read more, order your copy of No Man’s Land by Abhishek Saha.

harperbroadcast

Recent Posts

Read an Excerpt from ‘The Keeper of Desolation’

Surreal yet gritty, violent yet poetic – such is the world of Chandan Pandey’s fiction.…

8 months ago

Mitali Mukherjee’s Favourite Books

From books on financial frauds to a graphic novel based in Gaza, Mitali Mukherjee reading…

8 months ago

Between the Lines with Mitali Mukherjee

Mitali Mukherjee's chilling and unputdownable new book Crypto Crimes traces the murky underbelly of the…

8 months ago

Mastering Money: Essential Reads in Finance and Business Books

Hey there readers! For today’s blog we have brought you a collection of finance and…

8 months ago

Explore The World of YA Novels Perfect for Teens

Hi readers! In this week’s blog we have some Young Adult recommendations perfect for teens.…

8 months ago

India’s #1 crime writer S. Hussain Zaidi is back with a riveting thriller – The Black Orphan

is proud to announce the release of THE BLACK ORPHAN   Inspired by true events,…

8 months ago